A lesson from The Agora
Disagreeing without losing the person
A disagreement has two outcomes, not one: the question, and the relationship. You can win both, but not by accident.
Step 1
Repeat theirs before you make yours
Say their case back to them, well enough that they'd accept it as fair — "so your worry is the cost falling on the newest members". People who feel understood stop defending and start thinking. It costs one sentence.
Step 2
Question the idea's load-bearing part
Not every flaw — the one the idea actually rests on. Piling up ten small objections feels like winning and persuades no one. One careful question at the foundation does more than a speech.
Step 3
Leave them a door
"I'd change my mind if X" — and mean it, and say what your X is. A disagreement where both people have named their doors ends as thinking. One where neither has ends as a wall.